As long as the government is still governing the country under
the policy of taxing, hoarding taxes for surpluses and profiteering
via fees and GLCs etc, PTC will never be fair or price the public
transportation costs in a fair and equitable manner.
Has the minister done his homework like working out the
percentage of transportation cost per family based on lower income
earners ?
Until the minister has done his home work PTC will always take
it to be the government signal to charge all costs based on
government's own policy of taxing and hoarding and
profiteering.
It will continue to charge higher and higher fees to make more
monies like the government is doing with taxing and hoarding and
profiteering.
It Raymond Lim is more people-centred he should have by now done
a table for reference by the PTC:-
(1) average family income at the lower 20-50% of population
(2) taxes and fees paid per family for basic necessities like
housing, medicare and utility and vehicle transportation etc for
the lower 20-50% of earners.
(3) From (1) minus (2) work out the Net disposable income after
deducting housing tax, vehicle tax and government charges on basic
necessities covering food, medicare etc.
(4) Balance will then form the Amount affordable for public
transportation per family in the lower income group.
Without working out such per-capital disposable income the
Public Transport Council will continue to increase the
transportation fees year after year by all sorts of excuses.
Many excuses given so far include:-
(1) inflation, wages, fuel, airconditioning, depreciations, new
investments, extra staff floats for all sorts of purposes,
share-holder returns (always the large chunk of fees go to paying
higher CEO wages, options, bonuses and higher reserves, and rentals
of all kinds including all the infrastructural costs which should
have been financed from government COE, ERP Road Tax, and Petrol
taxes etc in the first instance.
(2) increases will be more frequent so as to keep each increase
smaller (like justifying the ministers' million dollar salaries to
avoid corruption)
(3) no free lunch or free rides.