Weird ley, why the captian cannot control his crew?
TS is already wrong, because this is hardly a test of
leadership. It is more of a case of moral judgement. However, this
is a badly designed question. This is because no matter you choose
the utilitarian approach or the deontological approach, both seems
to point at A.
A harder one would be... Supposed a fat man is standing beside
you on a bridge. You see a train which lost control and chiong-ing
down the tracks. In addition, some madman has tied 5 people to the
tracks. You know that if you push this fat man down, you will be
able to stop the train and hence save the 5 people. However, the
fat man will die. Yet, if you don't push the fat man down, 5 lives
would be lost instead.
In the above scenario, which one would you choose?
