An excerpt of a recent query by Steve Chia during Parliment.
Let's see what everyone's view is on this.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MARRIAGE RESTRICTION POLICY
11. Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong asked the Minister for Manpower (a)
under what basis can the appeal of a Singapore citizen who had a
relationship with an ex-work permit holder, resulting in the birth
of a child, be granted approval for marriage; and (b) in view of
our declining population figure, will such relationships resulting
in the birth of a child be given easier approval for marriage by
the Ministry.
The Senior Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Manpower (Mr
Hawazi Daipi) (for the Minister for Manpower): Sir, there are
presently more than 500,000 foreign work permit holders in
Singapore. To maintain our social equilibrium, these large numbers
of foreign workers are allowed to work in Singapore only if they
agree to our marriage restriction policy. Those who marry without
approval will be repatriated and disallowed entry into Singapore.
This is made clear to all foreign worker applicants who apply to
work in Singapore. This strict enforcement is necessary to maintain
this policy. Therefore, all current and ex-work permit holders are
reminded to adhere to this pre-condition to which they have agreed
upon.
Appeals will be considered on an individual basis.
Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong (Non-Constituency Member): Sir, the Senior
Parliamentary Secretary has not answered my question. How then can
the child, who is born out of wedlock from a Singaporean and an
ex-work permit worker, where they did not get married, but they
have a relationship and a child was conceived in that process, now
be able to live in an intact family in Singapore? Under what basis
would the Ministry allow approval for the marriage to pass
through?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: To start with, they are not allowed to live here
and, more so, to have children. It is precisely because we have to
control the population size of Singapore that we have to have this
condition agreed upon when a foreign worker applies to work in
Singapore. So he knows that he cannot contravene this marriage
restriction policy and if he wants to get married to a potential
Singaporean spouse, he has to seek approval. But if he is not given
approval, he may be repatriated.
Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong: Sir, a mistake has been made by the
child's parents where they actually entered into a relationship and
have a child. In view of Singapore's declining population, is it
not a helpful addition to the population when we have some new
children being born for the sake of Singapore? Basically, my
question is: why is the Ministry so "cruel" as to "punish" the
child by not allowing their parents to get married and stay
together as an intact family?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: Sir, the Ministry is not "cruel". In fact, we
consider applications for marriage between Singaporeans and ex-work
permit holders on an individual basis and allow, whenever possible,
where they meet the conditions. However, we have to protect the
interests of Singaporeans. As I have said earlier, we have more
than 500,000 foreigners working in Singapore and larger numbers of
them used to work in Singapore. So imagine if every other ex-work
permit holder were to marry a Singaporean, we would not be able to
manage our social services and social system. So I think Mr Chia
must bear this in mind and be fair to Singaporeans in general
first.
Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong: The Senior Parliamentary Secretary has not
answered my question. Under what basis would an appeal be approved?
The application for one of the residents was rejected after an
appeal. I am trying to find out what is the basis for
approval.
Mr Hawazi Daipi: Sir, we would consider on an individual basis the
merits of the application. But, generally, all work permit holders
know that they have agreed to abide by the marriage policy in
Singapore before they are allowed to obtain a work permit and work
in Singapore. That is the condition that all work permit applicants
must understand and adhere to. To be fair to potential children of
the future, they must ensure that they have to get approval to get
married.
Ms Braema Mathiaparanam: May I please ask the Senior Parliamentary
Secretary how many such cases have been approved on a case-by-case
basis? And of these cases that have gotten approval, how many have
become dependent on our social support services? In other words,
have they been responsible enough to take care of their own
families?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: Sir, I do not have the figures here. But in any
case, what is more important is to ensure that everyone -
Singaporeans and foreign workers working in Singapore - understands
that Singapore is a small place and we have limited resources. Even
though we want to increase our population size, we have to ensure
that those who want to live and have families in Singapore can look
after themselves, their children and their families. That is the
basic premise that we all must understand. I can only go back to
the earlier answer that I have given that all foreign workers who
want to work in Singapore must understand and agree to abide by
this basic principle.
Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong: Sir, if the Singaporean father undertakes
to take care and raise up a child with his own resources, is that a
good enough undertaking for approval?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: A child would need a motherly figure to look after
him. A father alone would not be able to do that, no matter how
much the father earns or is able to afford to look after the child.
So it is very important. If we want to be really fair to the child,
we have to understand the marriage restriction policy. And if they
qualify, then they get married. But wherever possible, ex-work
permit holders can be allowed to marry Singaporeans on a
case-by-case basis.
Dr Wang Kai Yuen (Bukit Timah): I would like to ask the Senior
Parliamentary Secretary whether a marriage can take place, under
universal law, at any place on earth and does not require the
approval of the Singapore Government. The Singapore Government can
only grant permission to get married in Singapore, as a result of
which, with our approval, they can gain residential status in
Singapore. Is that a fact?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: Can the Member simplify his question?
Dr Wang Kai Yuen: My question is whether anyone would need the
approval of Government to get married.
Mr Hawazi Daipi: No, only for work permit holders and this is a
specific group of people.
Dr Wang Kai Yuen: Including work permit holders, they can get
married anywhere in the world without our approval.
Mr Hawazi Daipi: Yes, it is a universal human right. However,
Singaporeans do have human rights to be able to look after
ourselves and manage our limited resources and to ensure that those
legitimate Singaporeans would be well looked after and would not
exact too much of our social system.
Mr Speaker: Last question, Mr Steve Chia.
Mr Steve Chia Kiah Hong: Does it mean that if the ex-work permit
holders are to get married overseas, they will be allowed to stay
in Singapore as an intact family?
Mr Hawazi Daipi: The simple answer is no, Sir.
