If a SMRT bus route is to be extended from Boon Lay Bus
Interchange to Joo Koon Bus Interchange, 172, 178, 180 and 187 are
the 4 bus routes to choose from. Through considering factors such
as length, advantages to the Jurong West
Extension area and possible implications,
I decided that route 180 is the SMRT bus route that should be
extended.
In terms of length, it would be good if the
route is the shortest, so that it is easier to manage and there
would not be much implication to the existing route when it gets
extended to Joo Koon. Currently, there are 4 SMRT bus services
originating from Boon Lay Bus Interchange, of which route 172 is
14.3km, route 178 is 29.6km, route 180 is 20.6km (with Bukit
Panjang Bus Interchange, it is around 10.1km) and route 187 is
24.4km.Therefore, since it is the shortest, route 180 should be the
SMRT bus route extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange.
In terms of advantages to the Jurong West Extension
area, it would be ideal if the extension of route can have
benefits to the people staying in Jurong West Extension area.
If route 180 is extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange, people
staying along Boon Lay
Way and Upper
Jurong Road will have a direct bus link to the Lakeside,
Chinese Garden, Bukit Batok and Bukit Panjang areas, besides Boon
Lay MRT station.
The extension of route 172
would benefit Jurong West Extension residents, in particular those
staying along Jurong West
Avenue 4, Jurong
West Street 61 and Upper Jurong Road. Therefore,
as the extended route covers more areas of the Jurong West
Extension residential areas, route 172 should be the SMRT bus route
extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange.
In terms of possible
implications, it would be good if the implications are
minimal and it is easy to compensate the loss. If route 180 is
extended, LTA would have to create a bus stop at the bridge near
Boon Lay MRT station and next to the Jurong Central Park, for
affected commuters to board 180 from Boon Lay MRT station/bus
interchange or transfer to there. If route 172 is extended,
affected commuters (mostly people in the Military) from Boon Lay
Bus Interchange going to Jalan Bahar and Old Choa Chu Kang Road
would have to "re-locate" to Chua Chu Kang Bus Interchange and take
172 from there. Those staying in Jurong West Extension can easily
board the bus from the possible extended section (at Jurong West
Avenue 4, Street 61 and Upper Jurong Road). However, those staying
nearer to Boon Lay MRT Station will nolonger have a direct bus link
to the cemetery area, Old Choa Chu Kang Road and the CCK
town(although it may be faster to get to the town via MRT), unless
service 405 becomes a regular service. Therefore, route 180 should
be the SMRT bus route extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange, as the
implications are minimal and it is easier to compensate the loss of
bus link resulted due to it being extended to Joo Koon Bus
Interchange.
In terms of
length and possible implications,
route 180 should be extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange as it is
currently the shortest route and if it is extended, there would be
minimal implications and it is easy to compensate the possible loss
of bus link resulted if it is re-routed. In terms of
advantages to the Jurong West Extension area,
route 172 should be extended to Joo Koon Bus Interchange as the
possible extended route of 172 would cover more residential areas
of Jurong West Extension than the possible extended route of 180.
Therefore, if a SMRT route is to be extended to Joo Koon Bus
Interchange, route 180 is the SMRT bus route that should be
extended.