Dear Duffy,
Love is like a glass, once broken, it cannot be mended back as it
is already smashed into smithereens.
You are actually indecisive of who to love. You cannot love two
people at the same time as for you will however once again be hurt
or hurt the other parties.
Choose and follow your heart. I cannot tell you what to do but I
can advise you should now be desisive enough over what had happened
previously.