THE CRUCIAL FIRST CONVERSATION
The key here is balance: Don't ramble on like a bore. Even if
you're the first inner city Native American midget to play in the
Super Bowl, she doesn't want you to slap that information on the
bar like a freshly caught fish?though she does want to know that
you're gainfully employed. The solution: Ask her what she does.
She'll be flattered that you asked ("You'd be amazed by how many
guys go on about their jobs without asking what I do," explains
Rachel, 30, an environmental consultant in Washington, DC). And
then she'll turn around and ask you what you do.
If, due to nervousness, your tendency is to keep asking questions
as a means of engagement, relax. Says Wolf, "Pepper her with
questions without offering up information, and she'll start to
withdraw." You'll be coming off like a stalker because you have
tons of info on her and she knows nothing about you. Give her time
to ask you questions?don't worry about the awkward silences. She
understands that these early conversations always have gaps in
them. "And give enough information that grounds you in the
neighborhood?you play in a local softball league, you volunteer
somewhere?so she knows you're not some drifter," says Wolf. You
also might want to work in that you're single, but be somewhat
clever. For example, if she asks you where you live, say, "My
goldfish and I live in the Nevsky Projects." And if you've got
kids, she probably wants to know that early on too. Wouldn't
you?
If she doesn't respond to your queries with parallel questions,
move on. "How well a man reads the verbal and nonverbal signs is
hugely important," says Gayle Beck, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist
specializing in human sexuality at the State University of New York
at Buffalo. If her jaw's locked up tighter than a tetanus victim's,
if she crosses her arms or turns away from you, if she seems
uncomfortable in anyway, abort the mission, or at least move
slower.
More on chatting her up:
"It makes me uncomfortable if a guy comments on my body in any way,
as in `You look really good in that skirt.' That's way too familiar
for just meeting someone. It's too obvious that you're trying to
pick me up."
?Karen, 27, St. Paul
"When John first approached me, he was clearly nervous. He just
sort of blurted out that he had a dog and a roommate who was a guy
who he was not sleeping with. And that he wasn't sleeping with the
dog, either. Oh, and that he didn't have a girlfriend. It was
clumsy, but it was very sweet, and his honesty was endearing. I
loved it."
?Sarah, 29, Madison, Wis.
"Whatever you do, check out my breasts and butt before you come
over. If I see your eyes go below my necklace once while we're
talking, you're out."
?Nancy, 28, New York City
"I've heard a lot of guys make the mistake of trying to flatter a
woman by comparing her to a celeb, as in 'Did anyone ever tell you
that you look just like Fiona Apple?' Well, that's taking a big
chance that the woman thinks Fiona Apple is way prettier than she
is, and that she likes Fiona Apple. Maybe for some reason she
really hates Fiona Apple. Then you're screwed."
?Anita, 26, New Orleans
"Making me laugh is key, but don't launch into stand-up. Let me
make you laugh some, or I'm going to extrapolate that everything is
about you, and you'll be that way in bed, too."
?Amy, 30, Toronto
"Rick wasn't that good looking?he was short and stocky and losing
his hair. But when he came up to me and started talking, he was
hilarious, and jokingly self-deprecating in a way that showed me he
didn't really care that he wasn't Tom Cruise, that he had a sense
of humor about himself. His confidence completely won me over and I
went home with him that night."
?Mirelle, 33, New York City
"If a guy is looking around the room, there's no way I'm going home
with him. No girl will. Even if I'm not your dream girl, talk to me
while we're together, then excuse yourself." ?Melissa, 30,
Miami
"In a crowded bar, if people are walking by and pushing you,
there's a way a guy can put his arm around you?not actually
touching you, but behind your back so he's sort of keeping you from
getting shoved. A man doesn't need to pick a fight with some guy
who accidentally steps on my toes, but it's nice if he's
protective."
?Kris, 27, Los Angeles
"I like to see a guy who's passionate about something, like
politics or music or anything. If he gets excited when he talks,
that's hot."
?Simone, 33, Providence
"I love it when a guy sort of mirrors my physical behavior, like
when I'm sitting across from him and I lean in to say something, I
like him to lean in. If I'm talking really fast, and he can keep up
with me, it makes me feel like we're in the same place. If I'm
being a little frenetic and he's slow and relaxed and laid-back, I
feel really far away."
?Carlie, 30, Salt Lake City
AS YOU MAKE YOUR SMOOTH EXIT
So the conversation has flowed as easily as the alcohol now flowing
through your veins. And damn if this woman isn't getting prettier
as closing time approaches. Many men, desperate to close the deal,
blow it in this last, crucial interaction. Now's not the time to
push, even if this may be the last time you'll see her. In fact,
being the master of chill at this juncture will have the desired
effect: You'll either leave with her 411, or with her willing form.
"Clearly, declaring your undying love or at least your undeniable
lust right away would be an ineffective deployment of mating
strategies," says Buss, who has studied sex strategies of more than
10,000 humans in 37 cultures around the world for his book, The
Evolution of Desire: Strategies of Human Mating (Basic, 1995). The
same goes for being physical if you're not absolutely positive it's
welcome, or even being too insistent about setting up a definite
date to see her in the future?you come off as desperate or pushy.
"Effective moves involve more subtlety," concludes Buss.
Your best closing-time remarks:
"If all of a guy's friends are leaving and he stays behind to talk
to you, there's suddenly a lot of pressure on. He should always
leave with his friends. He can simply say he doesn't want to ditch
them, then ask if he can call me. He comes off like a good pal and
not just someone on the make."
?Diana, 24, New York City
"The best thing he can do is try to make a date off of our common
interests. If we were talking about golf, 'We should go to a
driving range sometime' is a great thing to say. It's not like the
pressure of a date, more like you're sports companions. If I want
to see you, I'll pick up on your invite."
?Phoebe, 32, Westport, Conn.
"A guy I talked to for a half hour in a bar actually kissed me
good-bye! It was only on the cheek, but it totally skeeved me out.
I didn't know if he thought he was giving me a taste of things to
come or what, but it was too forward. I had already given him my
number, but I never called him back."
?Eve, 24, College Park, Pa.
"Politeness is always a good thing. A simple handshake and 'I
enjoyed meeting you, I'd love to talk to you again,' with a
suggestion of a specific exhibition or a show to see is great. That
would make me feel like a guy has it together."
?Aimee, 26, Berkeley, Calif.
"If you're inviting her to do something in the future, even if
vaguely, it's best not to make it another bar or, even worse, the
same bar you're presently in. You seem like you have nothing going
on but drinking."
?Wendy, 28, Darien, Conn.
"I used to give out my number, but there are so many damn freaks
out there that if I like a guy, I'll ask for his number. The
coolest thing is if a guy offers me his number. It shows he's not
afraid I'll leave him sitting by the phone?he doesn't need to be
the one in total control, and that shows confidence. Sexy."
?Marnie, 24, Detroit
"Even if I'm really into a guy, he loses nothing by leaving without
trying to take me home. This is how he should play it with a woman.
He should say, 'It's getting late, do you want to go someplace for
a nightcap?' If she declines, ask for her number; if she says she
doesn't give her number out, volunteer yours. Then say good night
and hope she calls. If I'm into a guy and want to be with him that
night, I won't let him go home alone. If I like him and want to see
him again, one of us will have the other's numbers. We won't lose
touch."
?Catherine, 31, Austin, Tex.
THE GREEN LIGHTS
You've got a nibble if you see any of these indications of
interest. Mind your manners and she'll be hooked.
° She asks you to act like her boyfriend to avoid a jerk. This is
the ultimate sign that she could envision you in that role. She's
placed you above the "jerk pool." Play it cool and have some fun
with it.
° She compliments you on virtually anything. Women are used to
receiving compliments, not giving them. So if she points out a
positive characteristic, you've impressed her.
° She's disagreeing but laughing. Flirtatious sarcasm, as in "Yeah,
right, like I believe that!" means she's into you. If she weren't,
she'd simply "Uh-huh" you into oblivion.
° She keeps asking you to repeat yourself. She's not allowing the
blasting music to come between the two of you. A suggestion of a
quieter corner to talk in will be well received.
° She laughs at your lame junior high school?level jokes. She's
obviously lust drunk. Or maybe just drunk.
° She touches you anywhere. Touch her back in the equivalent place,
and let her up the ante, just in case her touch was an accidental
slip of the hand.
° She stays put. If you run to drain the monster and she's still
where you left her when you return, you're doing something right.
Likewise if she comes back to you after she powders her nose.
° She doesn't flinch. If you reach across her to grab a drink or an
ashtray and she doesn't pull back, she's feeling physically
comfortable with you. Don't blow it, pal.
° She says, "Hey, where ya goin'?" as you leave the bar. She's
angling for an invite. Even if she ultimately says no (she may not
feel safe going off with you or may not want to ditch her friends)
it's a sign she's game for a future hookup.