Are you having the same one as me? Mine is the luminous
packing.
It is only OK, no clumps. But it
smudges. Soft - so not for my liking.
I am still looking for waterproof, smudge free, hard, long
extended curly curly mascara.
i wore it for a full day..it smudge at e end of the day..
but its still ez to remove using MU remover..