Could meditation really help
slow the ageing process?
James
Kingsland 3 March 2016 The
Guardian
There is a
small but growing body of evidence that regular meditation really
can slow ageing, at least at the cellular level.
Do people who meditate age more slowly? It
seems unlikely on the face of it. How could sitting immobile with
one’s eyes closed, perhaps focusing on the breath, possibly keep
the Grim Reaper at bay? That said, the Buddha – surely the
archetypal meditator – is reputed to have lived to 80, which must
have been an exceptionally ripe old age in 5th century BCE India.
And according to Buddhist scriptures, even after 80 years in this
realm of existence, in the end it wasn’t old age that finished him
off but food poisoning.
Two and a half millennia later there is a small but growing body of
evidence thatregular meditation
really can slow ageing –
at least at the cellular level. A commonly used proxy for cellular
ageing is the length of telomeres,
the DNA and protein caps that protect the ends of each chromosome
during cell division. These shorten slightly every time the
chromosome replicates, until eventually the cell can no longer
divide, becoming senescent or undergoing “apoptosis” – the cellular
equivalent of suicide. Having shorter telomeres in your cells is
associated with the onset of many age-related diseases, including
hypertension, cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes and dementia.
Several lifestyle factors have been found to accelerate telomere
shortening, such as poor
diet,
lack of sleep, smoking, drinking and a sedentary
lifestyle.
Chronic
stress is also known to accelerate the
shortening of telomeres. A study published last
month found that long-term meditators
had a reduced inflammatory and stress response to psychological and
chemical stressors in the lab compared with a control group. By
countering the effects of stress, could meditation also indirectly
slow cellular ageing? An older
study found increased telomere length
in the immune cells of people after they took part in an intensive
meditation retreat. Another revealed
increased activity of an enzyme called telomerase, which rebuilds
telomeres, after a similar retreat.
Now a study by Spanish
researchers suggests that highly experienced Zen
meditators have longer telomeres on average than people of a
similar age and lifestyle. The research also hints that the
psychological factors underpinning this beneficial effect were that
the meditators had a more compassionate, accepting outlook on
life.
Scientists at the University of Zaragoza compared 20 people who had
been practising Zen meditation for an hour or more a day for at
least 10 years with 20 people who had never meditated, matched for
age, sex and lifestyle factors such as diet, smoking, drinking and
exercise. All of them were subjected to a battery of psychological
tests and gave blood samples so that the length of telomeres in
their immune cells could be measured.
When the researchers crunched the data they found that the
meditators’ telomeres were significantly longer than those of the
controls, by an average of 10%. They then used a statistical
technique called regression analysis to get an idea which factors
might be directly responsible for this apparent slowing of cellular
ageing. Many psychological traits were associated with having
longer telomeres, including greater mindfulness skills, life
satisfaction and subjective happiness. But the statistical analysis
suggested that only younger age, low “experiential avoidance” and
high self-compassion were directly responsible for longer
telomeres.
Experiential
avoidance is
the natural tendency to suppress painful memories, thoughts,
emotions and sensations in an effort to gain temporary relief from
psychological discomfort. In fact, this mental shying away seems to
cause greater problems for us in the long-run. By
contrast, mindfulness –
both in its original Buddhist context and in modern therapeutic
programmes for treating conditions such as chronic pain, depression
and drug addiction – involves turning one’s
attention towards unpleasant
physical and mental experiences in a spirit of nonjudgmental
acceptance. So it’s particularly interesting that the Spanish study
found that experiential avoidance seemingly leads to faster
shortening of telomeres.
So can we add meditation to
the list of lifestyle changes, alongside giving up smoking,
exercising more and drinking less, that can lead to a longer,
healthier life? It’s worth bearing in mind that this study only
measured cellular ageing. And it was a very
small study, with only 40 participants in total, which limits the
conclusions that can reliably be drawn. The meditators were also
exceptionally experienced, having clocked up at least a decade of
practice. Ideally, a future study should randomly assign a much
larger number of people who have never meditated either to a
meditation programme or an equivalent activity, such as relaxation
training, and compare the effects on telomere length over a much
shorter period – perhaps just a few months.
There’s cause for optimism, though, that even beginners can start
protecting their telomeres from the ravages of time and cell
division. A study published in
2013found
that just 15 minutes’ meditation in novices had immediate effects
on the expression of many genes, for example increasing the
activity of the gene that makes telomerase and reducing the
activity of genes involved in inflammatory and stress responses.
It’s amazing what sitting still with your eyes closed and focusing
on your breath can do for your cells.