To be happier,
start thinking more about your death
Arthur C
Brooks | NYT News Service
| Jan 15, 2016
Want a better 2016? Try
thinking more about your impending demise.
Years ago on a visit to Thailand, I was surprised to learn that
Buddhist monks often contemplate the photos of corpses in various
stages of decay. The Buddha himself recommended corpse meditation.
"This body, too," students were taught to say about their own
bodies, "such is its nature, such is its future, such its
unavoidable fate."
Paradoxically, this meditation on death is intended as a key to
better living. It makes disciples aware of the transitory nature of
their own physical lives and stimulates a realignment between
momentary desires and existential goals. In other words, it makes
one ask, "Am I making the right use of my scarce and precious
life?"
In fact, most people suffer grave misalignment. In a 2004 article
in the journal Science, a team of scholars, including the Nobel
Prize winner Daniel Kahneman, surveyed a group of women to compare
how much satisfaction they derived from their daily activities.
Among voluntary activities, we might expect that choices would
roughly align with satisfaction. Not so. The women reported
deriving more satisfaction from prayer, worship and meditation than
from watching television. Yet the average respondent spent more
than five times as long watching TV as engaging in spiritual
activities.
If anything, this study understates the misalignment problem. The
American Time Use Survey from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows
that, in 2014, the average US adult spent four times longer
watching television than "socializing and communicating," and 20
times longer on TV than on "religious and spiritual activities."
The survey did not ask about hours surfing the web, but we can
imagine a similar disparity.
This misalignment leads to ennui and regret. I'm reminded of a
friend who was hopelessly addicted to British crossword puzzles
(the ones with clues that seem inscrutable to Americans, such as,
"The portly gentleman ate his cat, backwards"). A harmless pastime,
right? My friend didn't think so — he was so wracked with guilt
after wasting hours that he consulted a psychotherapist about how
to quit. (The advice: Schedule a reasonable amount of time for
crosswords and stop feeling guilty.)
While few people share my friend's interest, many share his
anxiety. Millions have resolved to waste less time in 2016 and have
already failed. I imagine some readers of this article are filled
with self-loathing because they just wasted 10 minutes on a
listicle titled "Celebrities With Terrible Skin."
Some might say that this reveals our true preferences for TV and
click bait over loved ones and God. But I believe it is an error in
decision making. Our days tend to be an exercise in distraction. We
think about the past and future more than the present; we are
mentally in one place and physically in another. Without
consciousness, we mindlessly blow the present moment on low-value
activities.
The secret is not simply a resolution to stop wasting time,
however. It is to find a systematic way to raise the scarcity of
time to our consciousness.
Even if contemplating a corpse is a bit too much, you can still
practice some of the Buddha's wisdom resolving to live as if 2016
were your last year. Then remorselessly root out activities, small
and large, that don't pass the "last-year test."
There are many creative
ways to practice this test. For example, if you plan a summer
vacation, consider what would you do for a week or two if this were
your last opportunity. With whom would you reconnect and spend some
time? Would you settle your soul on a silent retreat, or instead
spend the time drunk in Cancun, Mexico?
If
this year were your last, would you spend the next hour mindlessly
checking your social media, or would you read something that
uplifts you instead? Would you compose a snarky comment on this
article, or use the time to call a friend to see how she is doing?
Hey, I'm not judging here.
Some might think that the
last-year test is impractical. As an acquaintance of mine joked,
"If I had one year to live, I'd run up my credit cards." In truth,
he probably wouldn't. In a new paper in the science journal PLOS
One, two psychologists looked at the present value of money when
people contemplated death. One might assume that when reminded of
death, people would greatly value current spending over future
spending. But that's not how it turned out. Considering death
actually made respondents less likely to want to blow money now
than other scenarios did.
Will cultivating awareness
of the scarcity of your time make you grim and serious? Not at all.
In fact, there is some evidence that contemplating death makes you
funnier. Two scholars in 2013 published an academic paper detailing
research in which they subliminally primed people to think about
either death or pain, and then asked them to caption cartoons.
Outside raters found the death-primed participants' captions to be
funnier.
There's still time to
rethink your resolutions. Forget losing weight and saving money.
Those are New Year's resolutions for amateurs. This year, improve
your alignment, and maybe get funnier in the process: Be fully
alive now by meditating on your demise. Happy 2016!