Sept 2, 2005
Heated debate
Case of arctic dog which died of heatstroke due to owner's neglect
angers animal lovers, who wonder if such dogs should be allowed
here
By Chong Chee Kin
STRICKEN by a skin condition, Wiskey, a one-year-old Siberian
husky, was about to be put down by its owner.
Another arctic dog - an Alaskan malamute - was not so fortunate. It
died after being left out in the hot sun and deprived of water by
its owner, 30-year-old events manager Lim Bee Leong.
That Mr Lim was fined $3,000 last week, when he could have been
jailed for neglect, did not sit well with animal lovers.
A day after news of his conviction broke, broker Jill Hum started
an online petition appealing to the Attorney-General's Chambers to
seek a deterrent sentence. The petition, which has so far gathered
more than 2,800 signatures, closed yesterday.

PHOTO: CHEW SENG KIM
The two cases have also opened up a bigger issue: Should arctic
dogs like the husky, malamute and samoyed even be allowed into
Singapore?
Bred for the harsh arctic climate, these dogs have a double coat of
fur, which means that they are ill-suited to the heat and humidity
here. So ill-suited, some dog lovers believe, that an import ban
should be placed on them.
This arctic dog was saved

PHOTO: CHEW SENG KIM
ONE-YEAR-OLD Siberian husky Wiskey was ill and plagued by a skin
condition before the Action for Singapore Dogs (ASD) stepped in to
care for it, saving it from being put down.
Now, it is recovering well under the care of ASD volunteer Roger
Wong and has been fitted with a protective collar to prevent it
from scratching its wounds.
Arctic dogs like Wiskey are bred for cold climates. They have a
double coat of fur, which means that they are ill-suited to the
heat and humidity in Singapore.
The number of licensed dogs here has been rising steadily in recent
years, up from 39,200 in 2003 to 43,000 this year. Of this number,
about 700 are arctic dogs, the vast majority of them Siberian
huskies.
At present, only aggressive breeds like the akita, pit bull and the
mastiff are banned here because of the potential dangers they pose
to humans. But ASD president Ricky Yeo believes arctic dogs should
be banned too.
'Ideally, arctic breeds should not be in a hot and humid climate
like ours,' he said. 'The high humidity causes problems for their
skin, which becomes a breeding ground for parasites and
mites.
'We cannot fathom any reason why these dogs should ever be in our
environment. They serve no practical purpose other than aesthetic,'
he added.
Ms Hum agreed. 'Sure, they are beautiful. I would love to own one
too, but I think it's too cruel to keep them here knowing that they
will never be completely comfortable in this climate.'
Their opinions will inevitably draw howls of protest from most
owners of arctic dogs, but at least one has voiced his
approval.
Former zoo chief Bernard Harrison, who owns a malamute and a husky,
agreed that keeping the dogs here is 'crazy'. 'They are simply not
designed for this kind of weather,' he said.
Mr Harrison, now a zoo consultant, adopted the two dogs five years
ago at the request of his friends because his home in the Upper
Thomson area has a large compound that allows plenty of room and
shade for them.
The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) said
the decision whether to ban arctic breeds should be left to the
authorities, albeit after consultation with the SPCA and
veterinarians.
Ms Deirdre Moss, SPCA's executive officer, noted that no country
had ever banned certain dog breeds because they were not suited for
the weather there.
'Whatever happened to the Alaskan malamute could happen to any dog
in similar circumstances - subjected to the hot sun without shade
and without any water.'
Owners of arctic dogs like Mr Melvin Sim, who owns a husky,
agreed.
'A husky, or any arctic dog, can be happy if the owner knows how to
take care of it. It would not be fair if all arctic dog owners are
punished because of one negligent owner,' he argued.
The Agri-Food and Veterinary Authority (AVA) said it is not
uncommon for arctic breeds to be kept here and in other Asian
countries.
Mr Madhavan Kannan, head of AVA's Centre for Animal Welfare and
Control, said: 'These dog breeds have been kept in Singapore for
many years and they can adapt to our climatic conditions.
Generally, owners should keep them in cool surroundings in view of
their thicker coat.'
But Mr Lim, who has now moved out of his Bukit Timah terrace house,
did not - and his malamute paid the price.
[email protected]