Is chinese martial arts the best in the world?

last SG · 2009-11-10T22:30:57+00:00

Only applying his logic. mayi jie jie got 6 limbs, so she's the most fearsome fighter in this forum.

Rooney9 SG

those foreigners lousy one lar. you mean those learn wrestling or MMA? or TKD or karate?

china so many masters, foreigners go fight them they want to die early eh?

fireng SG

But I thought that due to his heroic status, it is very difficult to discern which is real or fake.

Like Bruce Lee lor. Alot of tv shows about both of them and some are fake and exagerated.

But if you do a search on Bruce Lee and Hou Yuanjia on the internet you can read alot of real battle fights that they participated in

ƒlame SG

ya Hou Yuan Jia. what about bruce lee master ip man, good or not?

You got see the blockbuster movie about him anot, the movie is make up of his biography hoh. See all the fight scene where Donnie Yen utilises Real Wing Chun techniques against different martial arts.

fireng SG

ya Hou Yuan Jia. what about bruce lee master ip man, good or not?

Only heard that he is good but never heard him challenging other martial art experts though..so his skills is like not tested..

ndmmxiaomayi SG

Other Wing Chun practioners did not have the chance or did not want to challenge other opponents from other martial arts background

Why did they not want to challenge other opponents?

Lokey SG

Chinese marital art, the reaction time is slower. The speed for throwing out the fist and kick is slow. There is too many unnecessary movement.

Depend on which Chinese kungfu…. actually really not very used.

I think for
attack : Muay Thai is fastest and powerful
defense: Aikido and Taiji
when the person is already down on the floor: BJJ
for more than one person, Aikido will be good.

ƒlame SG

Want the best Kung Fu, go to Shaolin Monastery

fireng SG

Why did they not want to challenge other opponents?

No chance lor. If they had travelled overseas and try to establish their own martial art school there like what Bruce Lee did than there will be many other opponents who will challenge them

Rooney9 SG

Only heard that he is good but never heard him challenging other martial art experts though..so his skills is like not tested..

you think foreigners damn good meh lol. or you are thinking of the wrestler from huo yuan jia movie lol. he is a real life wrestler though.

ndmmxiaomayi SG

Chinese marital art, the reaction time is slower. The speed for throwing out the fist and kick is slow. There is too many unnecessary movement.

Depend on which Chinese kungfu…. actually really not very used.

I think for
attack : Muay Thai is fastest and powerful
defense: Aikido and Taiji
when the person is already down on the floor: BJJ
for more than one person, Aikido will be good.

Think you seen too much modern wushu... if you can find a traditional art and learn it, you will see how much it differs from modern day wushu.

Rooney9 SG

Why did they not want to challenge other opponents?

cos they not after fame and hao lian. they just want to practise their craft quietly, not like some.

ƒlame SG

From my experience with fighting with one of my close buddy who learnt TKD and is a brown belt holder, they throw many nice kicks but the time needed for them to recoup is long, especially that Axe kick, I hate it.

fireng SG

you think foreigners damn good meh lol. or you are thinking of the wrestler from huo yuan jia movie lol. he is a real life wrestler though.

No I don't think they are good. lol

But I don't think Ip Man and Huang Feihong is good too cos their skills are like not tested against other opponents

ƒlame SG

bruce lee wanted to promote chinese Kung Fu to the whole world.

fireng SG

Think you seen too much modern wushu... if you can find a traditional art and learn it, you will see how much it differs from modern day wushu.

Actually Bruce Lee said before too that modern wushu have too many unecessary movement which is why he created Jeet Kund Do

Alp SG

I remember this question was posed to one of the student in the anime Kenichi (martial-arts type).

If memory serve me well, the question was:

Q: Among the masters in this dojo, which is the best martial arts in the world?

A: Whichever martial art that dominates and survives in today's context is the best.

I wondered if that made any sense at all...perhaps it did...

ndmmxiaomayi SG

No chance lor. If they had travelled overseas and try to establish their own martial art school there like what Bruce Lee did than there will be many other opponents who will challenge them

That has no link at all...

Why should someone starting a school to promote an art challenge someone else ?

Rooney9 SG

Actually Bruce Lee said before too that modern wushu have too many unecessary movement which is why he created Jeet Kund Do

yes good and nice to watch and see, but in real life fight, have no place in it. wushu also got san da, which is like TKD or thai boxing. san da is unlike the traditional wushu movements.

ƒlame SG

That has no link at all...

Why should someone starting a school to promote an art challenge someone else ?

To prove which martial art is better

Lokey SG

To prove which martial art is better

Actually it make no point. When you do marital art up a certain level, your movement and skills is not restricted by what you have learnt in your younger days, ultimately you will create your own style of fighting.

« Previous Page Next Page »