IDE didn't support hot-swapping. It never did. SCSI did,
though.
The plug-and-play function also depends on your mobo in
question. Older Intel mobos didn't support hot-swap through th
Southbridge. They implemented a special controller for that.
There is no disadvantages of using AHCI over IDE. Only
advantages. To enable it so the system does not crash, download the
proper drivers for your mobo. Install them, and then switch. If it
fails, you should get a failed boot-up with error quote,
'INACCESSIBLE_BOOT_DEVICE), then retry in IDE mode and reinstall.
It all depends on your mobo chipset, though. What chipset you
using?