for the acidic hydrolysis of nitrile to form carboxylic acid, i
was penalised for using Conc h2so4, HUR, instead of dilute h2so4,
heat under reflux
is it liable to be penalised for reagents and conditions that
can work, albeit unnecessary?
e.g. a rxn can procede with conc acid, or another rxn can
proceed without heat, e.g. for the electrophillic addn of Br2 (aq)
to phenol, or E add of hbr to alkene, can happen at room temp, but
if a student write heat, will still be penalised becos unsure the
rxn need input (heat) energy or not?
Concentration H2SO4 is for dehydration, not hydrolysis. Of course
u'll be penalized lah! Sheeesshh!!!
Yes, u'll be penalized if u write heat when rtp will suffice,
coz it tells Cambridge that u dunno ur Chem reagents &
conditions, and no boss will hire u as a chemist coz u're wasting
his electricity and money and resources to do unnecessary
nonsense.