Ex-HCJC student XinLin's blog entry :
http://stopthe-pretence.blogspot.sg/2012/03/truth-behind-my-jc-life.html
Ex-MOE teacher NeuroticRambling's blog entry on XinLin's
blog entry :
http://neurotic-ramblings-sg.blogspot.sg/2013/05/a-response-to-ugly-truth-about-hwa.html
Visitor MrSoonToBeLawyer's comments on NeuroticRambling's
blog entry about XinLin's blog entry :
My sympathy with XL (if any) is extremely limited. I studied at
HCI and HCJC two years ago and i'll go as far as admitting that it
is a high stress environment which is very demanding but i'll stop
short of calling it flawed. every now and then it is necessary to
stop and understand that nowhere in this world does there exist a
utopia and if we should attempt to compare it to our projected
ideals, then everything will fall short and appear flawed.
If there is one really important thing i learnt from my HC
experience, it is that being able to adapt to your environment is
extremely important for your success. evidently, it appears that
the real problem lies not in the misrepresentation of data, or
incompetent teachers or whatnot. These are not problems exclusive
to her but they are not problems which affect everybody. The reason
for that lies in our perception of a problem and our capacity to
reconfigure ourselves in order to overcome these perceived
problems. Clearly, XL lacks the skills required to operate in a
demanding environment and should not even be in HC.
XL makes vague and shady assertions about how she was tricked into
joining HC. I find this wholly ridiculous and comical. If she
wasn't satisfied, she could have left. Was she expecting a complete
change to take place just for her? God knows what was going through
her head.
I was in a CCA that trained 4 times a week, i headed a CIP project,
i took up a H3 subject in J2, and i got 3 gold medals, straight As
for A levels, including my H3 subject, PW and GP. This July, i'll
be beginning my term at oxford where i'll be studying law. So i
would urge anyone quick to sympathise or empathise with XL to take
a step back and understand that problems are not problems unless
you make them to be problems and refuse to budge and expect the
whole world to change to suit you.
Nobody denies that elitism exists. but i am eternally grateful for
this education as it has provided me with so much more beyond the
mountains of readings and projects. An elite education is not for
everyone. Not everyone can handle it, and not everyone deserves it.
You reap what you sow, and if you're lazy and immature and intend
to work inconsistently, don't be too surprised with an ABBBC. if
you want to be recognised and want to prove yourself, better damn
well work for it and stop whining because NOBODY CARES.
Visitor FuckYouMrSoonToBeLawyer on
Visitor MrSoonToBeLawyer's comments on NeuroticRambling's
blog entry about XinLin's blog entry :
"My sympathy with XL (if any) is extremely limited. I studied at
HCI and HCJC two years ago and i'll go as far as admitting that it
is a high stress environment which is very demanding but i'll stop
short of calling it flawed. every now and then it is necessary to
stop and understand that nowhere in this world does there exist a
utopia and if we should attempt to compare it to our projected
ideals, then everything will fall short and appear flawed."
First off: What do you consider a utopia. Your own version of a
utopia may not coincide with hers, or even conflict with her.
From what I have read, XL's post is about waking up from her own
disillusioned self, and being stronger in that aspect. I never seen
her say ranting about how she hated HCJC for all the experience
that it has given her.
"If there is one really important thing i learnt from my HC
experience, it is that being able to adapt to your environment is
extremely important for your success. evidently, it appears that
the real problem lies not in the misrepresentation of data, or
incompetent teachers or whatnot. These are not problems exclusive
to her but they are not problems which affect everybody. The reason
for that lies in our perception of a problem and our capacity to
reconfigure ourselves in order to overcome these perceived
problems. Clearly, XL lacks the skills required to operate in a
demanding environment and should not even be in HC."
Oh please. What she bring up is her own experience a posteriori.
Yes both of you acknowledge that the problem exist. And while I do
agree with you that adapting to your environment is crucial to
attaining success, there is a thing called aptitude. Not everyone
is so "mightly high" as you. If I read correctly, her strengths are
in Chinese Dance. Supposing I put you in a Chinese Dance School
with her, would you have done as well as her? While I do agree that
she could be a misfit to your oh so "high mightly" HC culture, it
does not mean that she just sat back and let the environment
conditions take over her thoughts, in which I will elaborate on the
next paragraph. She did try to learn the skills to adapt to JC
life, albeit unsuccessful. And to say that she should not be in HC.
She earned the f****** right to go to HC and learn there.
"XL makes vague and shady assertions about how she was tricked into
joining HC. I find this wholly ridiculous and comical. If she
wasn't satisfied, she could have left. Was she expecting a complete
change to take place just for her? God knows what was going through
her head."
This is when I have to take a tough stand against your ridiculous
statement. Have you read through her whole post? From the bloody
original site. She tried her upmost best to adapt to the
saturation. If not she could have given up and became a playgirl.
And leaving JC is not as easy as snapping your finger. Please think
about it. Potential disruption to your current life should be
minimized. Hence staying in HCJC and doing your best there should
be a better option.
She should be given credit for trying hard, especially before her
exams. Her consultations to the teachers, her all nighters. Her
sweat and tears are not for nothing, as she grows up a more mature
woman. SHE DOES NOT CERTAINLY WAIT FOR A COMPLETE CHANGE, as you
have asserted.
AND GOD FORBID YOU TO KNOW WHAT IS GOING IN THROUGH HER HEAD, YOU
STUPID, and yes I do mean it in a literal way.
"I was in a CCA that trained 4 times a week, i headed a CIP
project, i took up a H3 subject in J2, and i got 3 gold medals,
straight As for A levels, including my H3 subject, PW and GP. This
July, i'll be beginning my term at oxford where i'll be studying
law. So i would urge anyone quick to sympathise or empathise with
XL to take a step back and understand that problems are not
problems unless you make them to be problems and refuse to budge
and expect the whole world to change to suit you."
While I am amazed at how much you have done, realize that you are
committing a fallacy, soon to be lawyer. I am not going to appeal
to your flawed logic. How does your achievements got to do with XL?
So take your egoism and your own achievements elsewhere and lets
concentrate on the main issue.
So what is your definition of problem? It is a situation in which
needs to be overcome. So you are proposing to ignore the
consequences of global warming cause you do not want to recognise
it as a problem? I will put you in the level of climate deniers
(together with science deniers) if u do agree.
A problem is not created intrinsically by you. IT IS AN EXTRINSTIC
ISSUE. An issue in which XL recognize and try to solve it within
her own means. And your last sentence in that paragraph does not
makes sense.
And while I do not have any sympathy or empathy with XL, she gains
my respect because she is head front in dealing with her own
problems and that she is willing to share with your
experience.
"Nobody denies that elitism exists. but i am eternally grateful for
this education as it has provided me with so much more beyond the
mountains of readings and projects. An elite education is not for
everyone. Not everyone can handle it, and not everyone deserves it.
You reap what you sow, and if you're lazy and immature and intend
to work inconsistently, don't be too surprised with an ABBBC. if
you want to be recognised and want to prove yourself, better damn
well work for it and stop whining because NOBODY CARES."
So tell me, soon to be lawyer, could your young self describe to me
how does the Boltzmann distribution comes about, including the full
derivation of the mathematical equation. Or the derivation of the
Gibbs Equation, both of which is sadly not taught or used in A
levels chemistry. Bloody hell. So grades are your knowledge or
aptitude about your subject huh? Let me pour cold water to your
elitist head, cause knowing discrete knowledge does not mean full
understanding and appreciation of the subject content itself. I
think you should quickly go to oxford and learn the error of your
ways, like what you have implied in your last sentence. Elite
education? FUCK YOU. I see Singapore education as a flawed pedagogy
as a whole. Elite education will be good education if it teaches
children how to truly learn, not cram for exams or as such. I
rest my case.