For most questions, it doesn’t matter whether you use chemical
or ionic equation, as long as you write your equations (whether
ionic or chemical) correctly, you will end up with the same correct
answer.
Consider the 1st question below. If you choose to use chemical
equation, you will have to take more care in balancing the chemical
equation, but you can apply stoichiometry directly. If you choose
to write ionic equation instead, the immediate stoichiometry is
simplier (1 proton combines with 1 hydroxide ion), but you will
have to do a further calculation to relate protons or hydroxide
ions to the acid or base. Eg. If molarity of protons = 0.9 mol/dm3,
then molarity of triprotic phosphoric(V) acid must be 0.9/3 = 0.3
mol/dm3.
There are some cases, in which you have to use ionic equation
instead. Eg. if there are 2 or more acids involved. From the amount
of base you use, calculate the amount of hydroxide ions involved.
Hence apply 1:1 stoichiometry and state the amount of protons
involved. Then apply further calculations to determine how much of
the protons came from one acid, and how much came from the
other.
Similarly, in the 2nd question below, you have to determine the
total no. of moles of ethandioate ions present (from both the acid
and the salt), by applying stoichiometry against KMnO4. Meaning, in
such questions, using the ionic (rather than chemical) equation
makes more sense.
The 2 questions which follow are considered challenging for ‘O’
levels (even ‘A’ level students struggle with them), so don’t
attempt them unless you’re sure of yourself. I will not be posting
detailed worked solutions to these questions, only the final
answers are given below.
Q1. Acid-Base stoichiometry.
125cm3 of a solution of phosphoric(V) acid were mixed with 75cm3 of
0.25mol/dm3 of barium hydroxide. A 50cm3 aliquot of the resultant
mixture required 7.5g of sodium carbonate for exact neutralization,
in which a gas was produced. By calculating the molarity of
phosphoric(V) acid used, calculate the sample mass of solid
phosphoric(V) acid that needs to be dissolved in 125cm3 of pure
water to prepare this molarity.
Ans :
The sample mass of solid phosphoric(V) acid that needs to be
dissolved is 19.7g
Q2. Redox + Acid-Base stoichiometry.
A solution contains a mixture of anhydrous ethanedioc acid, and
sodium ethanedioate. 25 cm3 of this solution required 20.0 cm3 of
0.10 mol/dm3 sodium hydroxide for neutralization using
phenolphthalein as indicator, and 28.0 cm3 of 0.02 mol/dm3 of
potassium manganate(VII) solution for complete oxidation at 60°C in
the presence of excess sulfuric acid. Calculate the molarity of the
acid and the salt.
Ans :
0.04 mol/dm3
0.016 mol/dm3