A top player he clearly isn't still... He may get better in
future or not we never know but at current level, he is still a
long way from the Rooney, the Berbatov or perhaps even
the Hernandez level...
If we are to think back carefully, he was sold at a time
when Ronaldo, Tevez and Ronney were still playing the strikers
position... So were United suppose to give him first
team spot just to keep him at the club? I don't think so...
Cos despite the education he has been getting these past few years
(presuming he has improved playing first choice in Spain) he
still isn't a top top striker that would command a $25 to $35
million transfer fee like... Benzema or Aguero kind...
Getting into the Italy squad isn't something to be wow
about nowadays... Perhaps 8 to 10 yrs ago it might have mean
something but today, the squad is at its lowest point and they are
trying to re-build... In the last WC finals, people were
saying there was not even one striker in the Italian squad that
would worry the opponents... And in a group together with Paraguay,
Slovakia, New Zealand... Italy ended in 4th place
behind even New Zealand can you even belief it ! ... That said
enough i think...
On Pique, if we are being honest... will you consider
replacing Rio or Vidic even today with him? let alone 2, 3 years
ago? The guy came from Barce's youth team and when they
came calling for him with a chance of playing for
Barcelona, naturally he would want to go
back... How many players wouldn't want to play for them
at this 'golden period'? Anyway, I don't think he is as good
as Rio or Vidic in the air which is a big part in English
football.
On Macheda, well... It's very much like the Rossi
situation isn't it... If the guy is patient and willing to wait for
his time... Maybe he will get his chance in future. But if he wants
to play now and clearly they can't give him that right now... Then
they will have to let him go too... Cos we have all seen how he
perform when he starts... Not very effective... So should United
keep him at the expense of the squad performance?
And like you have said Fergie will have a (healthy) headache
next season but I think Owen will leave, Diouf might get sold
or loan again... Macheda might come back or continue his loan for
another season... And Welbeck will come back? Or maybe Owen will
stay cos his salary is so low can keep him just to make Pool
unhappy... lol. Anyway, the guy can still score lah...
So when we think of why they had to be sold or let go... It's
just part of the game. But these young players help the club
earn good profits. Macheda today is still behind Hernandez
just like Rossi was to Van Nisterlrooy and Saha... If he cannot
wait, then he have to go. But I always believed if you are good
enough, you will make the first team... and Rossi
wasn't...
Anyway, if he indeed gets better, Fergie still have first
option to buy him back. But Fergie haven't made any move to
bring him back...