If Smith were to join them, he'd be in a worse situation than he
is currently in. At least at United, he's bound to get some games
due to the relative shortage of strikers.
At Newcastle, the striking department seems to be pretty well
stocked at the moment. Viduka, Owen, Martins and Ameobi competing
for 4 places. Owen is seemingly less fragile now, so it's most
likely gonna be rotational for them next season. And where would
dear old Smudger fit in then?
A better option would be to go to Everton. Moyes has rather
consistently kept them in the top half of the table, and a battler
like Smith should fit in well there. Especially if AJ is injured or
they wish to play with midfield scorers, Smith's ability to hold up
play and get out of the way for Arteta or Cahill to score would be
invaluable. Especially since they'restrike force too looks
threadbare, and Beattie looks to be on his way out.