Do you agree that the Venetian government played a vital
role in the rise of Venice as a great city-state?
EYA.
I agree that the Venetian government played a vital role in the
rise of Venice as a great city-state. However, there was another
important factor. This was the economic factor - trade monopoly and
the venetains' adventurous spirit.
The government played a vital role because of an exemplary
political system, a fair election system, capable leaders and
practical policies.
Venice had a very strong government - while European states
practised feudalism, Venice was a repulic as the leaders were
elected and this was closest to modern day democracy. Election was
based on nomination, balloting and voting to ensure that there was
no nepotism nor incompetent leaders. In the beginning, the leaders
were forward looking and capable. Talented people were elected to
serve in government. Practical polices were implmented to respond
to the demands of a changing environment eg paying prirates to stop
harassing its trading ships until they built up a strong navy. The
Venetian government also accommodated the stronger powers to the
weaker ones. The Signoria was formed to check on power such that
dictatorship was not allowed so as to secure the loyalty of the
people.
Economic factors were equally important in accounting for the rise
of Venice. Venice used its navy to destroy trade competitors to
control the sea routes and thus enjoy trade monopoly, especially in
salt. Venetians also travelled overland in search of business,
fortune and adventurer and explorer. Banking and finacial services
were offered to other traders - such economic foresight led to the
further rise of Venice.
The government (political factors) played a more important role
than the economic factors because a stalbe political climate is the
most essential if trade were to prosper. If the venetian government
was weak, chaos and disorder would result. Who then, would want to
trade with Venice? So, since the strong Venetian government ensured
that there was peace, democracy and political might, Venice
continued to rise even faster as they enjoyed a prosperous trade
monopoly through their adventurous spirit of discovery.
All factors are inter-linked and they led to the rapid rise of
Venice as a great city state. There can be no isolation of
factors.