Messed up argument indeed.
If you guys want to continue any argument.
Both sides pls post your stands one by one.
Then if the both stands from the sides(i take it atheists vs
theists?) clashes, both sides post their explaination with
evidence. If one sides see something wrong about the explaination,
counter it. there need not be a conclusion or result, since both
sides have their perspective for things. But this can help clear
things up and at least let spectators know what we are arguing for
and about.
Then we see who wins... 
Alternatively, continue the "laughable" discussion.
