While these durable, lightweight and undeniably trendy bottles
seem like the perfect choice for the health-conscious consumer,
scientific evidence indicates that the very plastic which makes the
bottles so ideal may pose serious health hazards.
The durability and beauty of the Nalgene bottle comes from the
material it is made of, Lexan polycarbonate resin. This plastic
polymer was developed by General Electric Plastics in 1953, when,
according to GE's Web site, (www.gelexan.com) Dr. Daniel W. Fox was
developing a polymer for wire insulation material.
Fox accidentally created a polymer that was unbreakable when it
hardened in a beaker, and patented this revolutionary material.
Lexan has been used over the years in a vast array of products,
including space helmet visors, bulletproof windows, compact discs
and DVDs, mobile phones, computers, baby bottles and, of course,
water bottles.
The Lexan bottles are marketed by a division of the Nalgene company
known as Nalgene Outdoor Products. Nalgene was founded in 1949, and
the company soon cornered the market on plastic laboratory
equipment. The outdoor products division was created in the 1970's
after the underground use of Nalgene products by outdoor
enthusiasts was made public.
Lexan was an ideal material for the water bottles both for its
durability and because the material neither holds odors or flavors
nor imparts any taste to fluids stored in it.
Nalgene has marketed its original gray Lexan water bottles for many
years, but sales increased dramatically in 2002 when a color
assortment made possible by GE's VISUALfx Lexan finishes was
launched.
The April 2003 volume of "Current Biology" published a study that
cast suspicion on all polycarbonate plastics, including
Lexan.
The principle author, Dr. Patricia Hunt of Case Western Reserve
University in Cleveland, Ohio, has spent many years researching
developmental abnormalities leading to miscarriage and birth
defects in mice.
In 1998, her lab documented a sudden, inexplicable increase in a
defect known as aneuploidy, which is an abnormal loss or gain of
chromosomes. In humans, aneuploidy usually leads to miscarriage, or
to disorders like Down Syndrome, which occurs when an embryo ends
up with three copies of chromosome 21, instead of the normal two
copies.
In Hunt's lab, the spontaneous increase in mouse aneuploidy was
eventually traced to a lab worker using a harsh detergent to clean
the polycarbonate mice cages and water bottles.
The detergent caused the plastic to leach one of its constituent
chemicals, bisphenol A (BPA), which has been shown in other studies
to mimic the female hormone estrogen. The researchers duplicated
the detergent accident, with the same end results.
They then conducted another experiment in which female mice were
given a daily dose of pure BPA, again with the same end result, and
they concluded that low doses of BPA had significant effects.
The polycarbonate industry has criticized the Hunt study, saying
that data from experiments on mice may not be transferable to
humans. The industry has also conducted its own studies with rats,
modeled on the Hunt study, which did not find the same
results.
In a November/December 2003 article for Sierra Magazine, Hunt
countered that the industry studies did not look at the effects of
BPA on eggs and embryos.
"The [plastics] industry says this is just rodent studies," she
said, "but we know that the human egg is more fragile than the
mouse egg. If we wait for really hard evidence in humans, it will
be too late."
A University of Missouri study in the July 2003 issue of
Environmental Health Perspectives further confirmed the Hunt
study's conclusions.
In addition to determining that used, or discolored, polycarbonate
plastics leach high amounts of BPA at room temperature, this study
found that detectable levels of BPA leach from brand-new
polycarbonate plastics at room temperature.
In other studies, BPA has been implicated in more than just
chromosomal disorders, and it is just one of many chemicals known
to be environmental endocrine disruptors -- synthetic chemicals
that interfere with hormonal messages that are central to important
body processes like growth and development.
According to the Web site for the 1996 book "Our Stolen Future,"
which introduced the field of endocrine disruption to the public,
BPA at levels "far beneath the levels currently deemed safe by
regulatory authorities" has been shown to have adverse effects on
prostate development and tumors, breast tissue development, and
sperm count.
A 2002 study even linked low levels of BPA to the creation and
enlargement of fat cells in the body, suggesting that exposure to
BPA may be a cause of obesity.
The Nalgene Outdoor Products web site now features a response to
concerns about BPA leaching, stating with confidence that their
product is safe. "Polycarbonate like that used in Nalgene bottles
has been studied, tested and safely used for more than 40 years in
products for human consumption," the site states.
Scientists studying endocrine disruption, however, suggest limiting
potential exposure to BPA as much as possible. In a presentation
last month in Eugene sponsored by the Oregon Environmental Council,
"Our Stolen Future" co-author Dr. John P. Meyers addressed the
issue.
"I personally recommend avoiding polycarbonate plastics -- don't
let them come into contact with your food or water," Meyers said.
"I think the science is strong enough to justify precautionary
measures today."
He added that despite industry assurances to the safety of
polycarbonate, baby bottles made from the material have "quietly
disappeared from the market."
Many studies have shown that the effects of endocrine disrupting
chemicals are most devastating during early development, so babies
are highly at risk.
Polycarbonate plastics are still used in a variety of products,
including plastic resins lining some food storage cans, dental
sealants, and the Nalgene Lexan bottles.
Polycarbonate products can be identified by the symbol "#7 PC" on
their recycling logos.
According to the Sierra Magazine article, plastics that are safer
to use for storing food and beverages include polypropylene,
designated "#5 PP," high-density polyethylene, designated "#2 HDPE"
and low-density polyethylene designated "#4 LDPE," none of which
are known to leach harmful substances.
Nalgene makes a HDPE bottle identical in size and shape to the more
popular Lexan model.
Single-use water bottles (the type bottled water is sold in) made
from polyethylene terephthalate, "#1 PET" or "PETE" are not
recommended for repeat use, as a study found they may leach a
carcinogenic substance known as DEHA.
The Sierra Magazine article suggests other hydration options,
including using only very mild detergents and warm water to wash
polycarbonate bottles, and discarding them as soon as they show
signs of discoloring; or avoiding plastics altogether in favor of
glass or lightweight stainless steel containers.
