Singapore Idol Vs Project Superstar (which would you choose)

dO|pH|n3 a.k.a JaMiE SG

I personally chose Singapore Idol. Their singing is much better than superstar.
They are about to connect with the audience easier. Though their singing may not be that good but at least is above standard. What do u think?

Nikar SG

I personally chose Singapore Idol. Their singing is much better than superstar.

i thought sly sings even worst than a drag queen? taufik no comments lah. he's average singer. bring him outta SG will become even worse than other countries' bathroom singers. Rolling Eyes

They are about to connect with the audience easier. Though their singing may not be that good but at least is above standard. What do u think?

connect with audience hor? connect what connect?
carnal connection is it?
anyway, SG idol only appeals to jiak-kantang kids loh. very fake indeed. Rolling Eyes

talk about looks, don't talk lah. olinda......i don't wanna say lah. u got see new zealand farm pigs anot?
daphne......she midget or what? gives me a very irksome rich-spoilt-bratty attitude and a "fun-american-girl" wannabe feeling leh.
maia quite ok lah, but nowwhere the elegant kind. say her petite princess also not accurate, say her ah-lian also quite fake. she's trying too hard lah.

this is still asia loh, sister. they wanna sing english songs, in the end, their english also not so good. their chinese......very jia-lak lah. like that how????!!!!

in the end, the two SG-Idol winners end up doing small ads like 7-Elevens and always get hired by the government to attend grassroots events etc.
they're more like SG ambassadors to me.
singers????? sure, break out of their SG-ambassador image first.

Gordonator SG

project superstar of course, it feels closer to home listening to chinese songs. something i can identify with. Wink

singapore idol seems too westenised.

Lord Kang SG

ya lor...totally agreed...Somemore project superstar got more pretty girls.. Embarassed

thoreldan SG

x10

and seriously how far can an english singer in singapore go??
compared to the huge chinese market in singapore/malaysia/hk/taiwan/china

starblue SG

i never really follow both... Laughing

Gordonator SG

u like who? chanel, candyce, kelly are not bad. Mr. Green

dO|pH|n3 a.k.a JaMiE SG

At least thir singing is better. Project Superstar winner cannot go far. Those can sing one was eliminated. Those cannot sing one was in the grand final.

The chinese market for singer to survive in the singing industry is too low. 9 out of ten cannot make it in Singapore let alone other countries.

dO|pH|n3 a.k.a JaMiE SG

Nikar
The way you say about them is like they are owning you one million dollars. They also have their weaknesses. Sly has its own unique voice at least better then those on channlel U though you might dislike his character.

parn SG

I second that, also agrees that Taufik is good. But...I've heard Kelly's single recently in gramaphone, it's nice too. Smile

105090 SG

notice that SUPERSTAR is Chinese medium, and my guess is it probably copies Singapore Idol.

SINGAPORE IDOL is english medium.. so you may expect diff audience groups and judging.. and i dun think superstar is officially recognised..

btw.. both i also dont like.. irritating and sick to see those ppl on the screen, tho my compliments to some contestants who sings quite nice..

caleb_chiang SG

Neither I guess... but I think Singapore Idol is held more professionally. Cool

Lord Kang SG

I like candyce, silver and kelly.... Embarassed

Gordonator SG

don't like chanel? the sassy girl type? Mr. Green

Nikar SG

The way you say about them is like they are owning you one million dollars. They also have their weaknesses. Sly has its own unique voice at least better then those on channlel U though you might dislike his character.

sly got own unique voice? really meh? i thought that kinda voice is average SG male voice? KNN, you reading too much into it, is it?

i tell you, xiao-mei-mei.......if SG got no true idol, then don't idolise lah! why die-die must idolize someone? go idolize some ah-pek on the streets better lah!
or idolize me lah. kor-kor bring you go gai-gai. KNN.

Lord Kang SG

Not really leh...Even though i like the one in "My Sassy Girlfriend", but i don't think i can have one man..haha..I prefer more bu dong girls..

Lim Beh Ka Li Kong SG

Rolling Eyes
That beh hoon kia piece of sh1t???

What's the big deal abt uniqueness? Being unique simply means tt he's different, but not necessarily good.

Anyway, u think he stand a chance next to JunYang, Derrick, Kelly or XinHui? Can ask him to wake up his f**king idea? He made it this far only becoz there are no other Chinese singers at Singapore Idol. On his own, he's NOTHING!!!

dO|pH|n3 a.k.a JaMiE SG

Hey watch your word over here. If you want to comment, please use the appropriate word. If you are unhappy, then don't pose loh. Susperstar has a lot of biasness. I DID not say SLy is the best.

Nikar, respect yourself. Btw, I am not a girl. we are talking about singing not idolism. Get it clear. Frankly speaking, they will not make it. I prefer Xin Hui.

ha8n SG

sad to say..i dun choose both of them

Lim Beh Ka Li Kong SG

What is wrong with my words? They are facts, and I certainly have better vocab then you here. If you can't even take negative comments abt your idol, then you should be out of forums. Everyone is entitled to his own views. To me, he still is a "beh hoon kia piece of sh1t".

Have you realised that there are 3 mistakes in your first para alone???
It should be post, not pose...
It should be Superstar, not Susperstar...
It should be bias, not biasness...

Pls check yourself before commenting on others...