Hi all, would like to check on an MCQ from 2013.
Which gases that go into the bottom of the blast furnace undergo
a reaction during the extraction of iron?
1. Carbon dioxide 2. Nitrogen 3. Oxygen
A. 1 only B. 1, 2 and 3 C. 1 and 3 only D. 3 only
Would you include nitrogen (forming nitrogen oxides) as your
answer?
Again, it's Cambridge's fault for setting ambiguous qns like these
(every year there'll be a couple of such qns, in which different
school teachers will disagree with each other and/or with
Cambridge, and teach their students different answers) at both O
levels and (especially) A levels.
The most correct answer (regardless of whether it's the answer
Cambridge wanted, which is always debatable for such qns), is that
all 3 gases do indeed react at the high temperatures present in
blast furnances (whether for extraction of iron from its ore, or
other purposes).
As nitrogen (the most abundant gas in the atmosphere) is inevitably
present in the air used by blast furnaces (air is afterall, the
cheapest source of oxygen, and obviously all industries are
profit-oriented and want to make as much money as possible by
reducing costs), at such high temperatures of blast furnaces, it's
inevitable that various oxides of nitrogen (NOx) are generated.
Such oxides of nitrogen are toxic to humans, and are known to be an
industrial medical health hazard for blast furnace workers.
While the O level syllabus doesn't specifically include mention of
this health hazard suffered by blast furnace workers, nonetheless
(assuming you believe Cambridge wants you to including nitrogen as
the correct answer) at O levels and A levels, students are arguably
expected to put 2 and 2 together (presence of nitrogen and oxygen,
and at high temperatures) and conclude oxides of nitrogen may (and
are) being produced in blast furnaces, albeit as undesirable (and
medically hazardous) side-products.
Yup, I'm a tutor and I raised this question to check the
consensus; its one of those that could be argued either
way.
Appreciated Jurongresident's detailed reply, apologies if he
spent the extra time to do it thinking I'm a student.
For what it's worth, the publishers (cambridge?) suggested
answer is only carbon dioxide and oxygen, but I thought a student
shouldn't be faulted to include nitrogen also.
Accounts of the need for NOX control in blast furnace has been
documented, within the secondary textbook; we might also link it to
the chapter on Air and Air pollution.
Alas, its one of those ambiguous questions for tutors and
students to take note.
TYS publishers are not certainly not Cambridge. TYS publishers pay
MOE for the right to publish the questions (the answers are by the
various authors hired by the publishers), as the copyrights are
co-owned by Cambridge and MOE. The official Cambridge mark schemes
are (by law, due to a legal agreement between MOE and Cambridge)
confidential and cannot be revealed to the public. It is fairly
common (especially for A levels, when it becomes even more
complicated) for all the different TYS publications available on
the market to all give different answers for an ambiguous,
challenging or problematic, open-ended Singapore A level exam
question (every year there's a couple of such qns). This happens
even for MCQs, but naturally to a lesser extent.