A levels H2 Chem
Topic : Organic Chem
For (C6H5)CH=CHCH3,
when this compound undergoes nitration, which position does the
propene direct the NO2+?
also when this molecule undergoes hydration in H3PO4, where does
the H+ and the OH- add since both carbon atoms have 1 R group. When
adding to an alkene, does length of R group affect the product or
only the number of R groups affect the product?
when an alkyl halide undergoes elimination, under sodium
hydroxide in alcoholic medium,
CH3CH2X -----> CH2=CH2 + HX
then,
HX + OH- -----> H2O +
X-
why does HX react with OH- ion when NaOH is in alcohoic medium,
so there aren't any OH- ions present?
also when reacting alkyl halide with ammonia in alcoholic
medium,
CH3CH2X + NH3(alc) ----->
CH3CH2NH2 + HX
why doesn't HX react with NH3 here?
Regard the alkene group as an alkyl group (by induction, it is
neither electron donating nor withdrawing; by resonance it can be
both electron donating and withdrawing). In other words, a weakly
activating, ortho-para directing substituent.
Accordingly, the product of the electrophilic aromatic
subtitution is generated as the NO2+ electrophile substitutes away
a proton on either the para position (since a propenyl group
presents significant steric hinderance) or the ortho position
(since there are two ortho positions versus one para position). For
A levels, you need to give both ortho and para isomeric
products.
During hydration of the alkene double bond, the more stable
carbocation intermediate will be the carbocation atom (ie. C with
+ve formal charge) bonded directly to the benzene ring, because the
benzene ring can stabilize the carbocation by both
induction/hyperconjugation and resonance, while the terminal methyl
group can stabilize the carbocation by induction/hyperconjugation
only.
Therefore, the major alcohol product will have the OH group
bonded to the C atom next to the benzene ring, since a more stable
intermediate means lower activation energy means faster rate of
reaction means more of *that* product formed, which we identify by
use of the label "major product".
As for length of alkyl chain, yes the greater the length, the
greater its electron-donating by induction capacity. Although this
is not usually tested at H2 Chem level, so just FYI.
The equation you quoted for elimination of HX from alkyl halides
using alcoholic OH- ions, is misleading. If you know the mechanism
(I encourage all H2 students to approach OC (Organic Chem) from an
understanding-of-mechanism instead of blind-route-memorization
approach), then you would realize that the equations given are
misleading.
The OH- ion in alcoholic solvent has a greater propensity to
behave as a base rather than a nucleophile (since the alcoholic
solvent affords less hydrogen bonding stabilization to the OH- ion
compared to aqueous water solvent). Understand that bases accept
protons in a bid to stabilize themselves. And so the OH- ion under
alcholic solvent functions as a base (and carries out elimination)
rather than as a nucleophile (to carry out substitution).
A Note on Nucleophilicity versus Basicity : Comparing F- with
I-, you should be able to articulate that F- is a stronger base
(since higher charge density = more unstable = more desperate to
protonate itself) while I- is a stronger nucleophile (since greater
ionic radius = electron charge clouds more polarizable = more
willing to donate dative bonds to electrophiles).
Mechanism of Elimination of HX :
The alcoholic OH- ion abstracts ("plucks") a beta proton; the sigma
bond between the beta carbon and beta proton becomes a pi bond
between the alpha and beta protons; without violating the alpha
carbon's octet thanks to halogen which leaves as a halide ion
(remember that halogens are good leaving groups because halide ions
are stable because of large ionic radius and thus low charge
density; of the halogens only F is a poor leaving group because F-
is unstable due to high charge density).
Accordingly, if you wish to represent the elimination reaction
with an equation (although the full mechanism is always
preferred).
CH3CH2X(alc) + OH-(alc) -----> CH2=CH2(alc) +
H2O(alc) + NaX(alc)
Write the above equation, and *not* the two step equation you
quoted (ignore your JC's notes, don't use or buy or study *any*
JC's lecture notes, every JC's notes are different and many are
often filled with nonsense, just use CS Toh's A level Study Guide
instead for the A levels).
Similarly, based on the mechanism, the nucleophilic attack of
ammonia on alkyl halides should be written as :
CH3CH2X(alc) + NH3(alc) ----->
CH3CH2NH3+X-(alc)
or
CH3CH2X(alc) + NH3(alc) ----->
CH3CH2NH3+(alc) + X-(alc)
Note that the positive formal charge is on the N atom on the
ammonium salt, because the N atom has 4 bond pairs and 0 lone
pairs, but N is in Grp V. To obtain the amine (ie. the conjugate
base form), simply deprotonate the ammonium salt using aqueous NaOH
or KOH.
CH3CH2NH3+X-(aq) + Na+OH-(aq) -----> CH3CH2NH2(aq) + H2O(aq)
+ Na+X-(aq)
or
CH3CH2NH3X(aq) + NaOH(aq) -----> CH3CH2NH2(aq) + H2O(aq) +
NaX(aq)