I won't take back my provocative question you quoted.
While the CJC one stems from impression, the fact of the matter is
that the argument has everything to do with impressions - not mine,
but others. Hence, even if the facts are far from the truth, the
damage has been done. While not all students are Catholics as you
correctly pointed out, it is rather damaging to the school
reputation and no doubt the Catholic in charge will be saddened if
he hears of it. Especially when the Catholic faith is so against
abortion and sexual promiscuity, more than the Protestants.
The ACS vs CHS one, it is regrettable that I can't find any stats
on CHS, now that they merged into HCI and their de-emphasis on
academic results. I could find the ACS one though, but it is
practically useless if I do not have the CHS one for comparison.
Hence, until the day I dig out the CHS one, I shall take back my
allegation, as per etiquette. I also
apologize for any bad feelings caused to any ACS student or
alumni.
However, I will not take back my question as I feel my allegations
are not far off from the truth, after all. I think there is no need
to lie, the average ACS student is not exactly proud of his chinese
result, in the academic sense.
Furthermore, if you ask them whether they think their chinese sucks
more or the CHS english sucks more, I suspect they will say their
chinese sucks more.