Originally posted by NeonTetra:
as much as the explanation do make some sense...they do not have
solid biblical backing. the making of images and veneration of
these are surely not allowed in the Bible.
You need to look closely at the verses in scripture that condemn
images. You will find that images are not to be made for worship.
Nothing condemns them being made for the purpose of directing our
minds and hearts to God. How can images be wrong when they
facilitate our prayer and worship of the One Lord?
if God knows humans like pictures so much..then y the bible is
all in words?
Firstly, in the early years of the Church, before the masses
knew how to read as they do today, pictures were used to teach the
people about Christ and the stories of the Bible. It is for that
reason that many stained-glass windows, paintings, and statues were
created. Also, if you look at the very first editions and printings
of the King James Bible--as well as similar bibles of that time
period--you will find that they are extensively adorned w/ wood
carvings and other artwork and illustrations.
Of course, today, since most Christians can read, the Bible is
mostly in words. Words are also the most effective way to get any
point across--much more effective then pictures. However, this does
not discredit the use of pictures to "illustrate" a story or to aid
our prayer life.
the bible also emphasise on a faith that require no sight. then
why keep insisting people need to see and touch some relics and
pictures in order to believe?
Catholics do not insist on these at all. We argue not that the
use of pictures and relics is absolutely necessary, but that the
use of them is an orthodox practice. This is a big difference.
Also, Catholics have plenty of "faith without seeing," the most
notable example being our belief in the Real Presence.
Grace from God is it tt limited that we need sacramentals such
as medals and scapulars to obtain? Christ's death is not powerful
and sufficient enough to make us worthy of God's grace? Mary dun
wear medals..yet she is highly favored and God's grace is on
her.
No one is claiming that medals and scapulars are absolutely
necessary. We can and do receive grace w/o them. We merely contend
that grace can also be received through the physical aided by the
spiritual.
Moses and all the biblical figures do not encounter God in bread
and images. They saw God in visions and out of faith.
For one thing, visions are images. Secondly, if manna from the
sky isn't people encountering God in bread, what do you call
it?
Pictorial representations, no matter how legitimate it seems on
human terms is not the right manner to remember, observe, worship
and honour God-the invisible.
We are merely claiming that it is right, not that it is THE
right way, or more right then any other way
Why dun we worship a picture of Jesus's brain so that we can
have the mind of Christ?
I repeat once again, we do not worship these images. We do not
worship paintings or statues of Jesus. No worship is being afforded
these things. Instead, these things direct our worship to
God.
Hence, in the devotion to the Sacred Heart, there are two elements:
a sensible element, the Heart of flesh, and a spiritual element,
that which this Heart of flesh recalls spiritual element, that
which this Heart of flesh recalls and represents. But these two
elements do not form two distinct objects, merely co-ordinated they
constitute but one, just as do the body and soul, and the sign and
the thing signified. Hence it is also understood that these two
elements are as essential to the devotion as body and soul are
essential to man. Of the two elements constituting the whole, the
principal one is love, which is as much the cause of the devotion
and its reason for existence as the soul is the principal element
in man. Consequently, devotion to the Sacred Heart may be defined
as devotion to the adorable Heart of Jesus Christ in so far as this
Heart represents and recalls His love; or, what amounts to the same
thing, devotion to the love of Jesus Christ in so far as this love
is recalled and symbolically represented to us by His Heart of
flesh.