I disagree with you. Based on my experience fighting with
Infantry, Guards , Armour and Cdo, all of them are different in
their own sense. Throw in the Arti, signals, engineers. All of them
are trained for a specific role. I think cannot compare 1 formation
with another and say who is better than who. All have different
training. Its like comparing an apple with an orange. Maybe
comparing NSF infantry with reservist unit might be more balanced.
I do see a difference btw NSF and reservist units. I can really see
the fighting spirits and experience in the reservist units.
I agree with you that Cdo training is tough. But they really think
that they are bullet proof, and simply charge at entrenched enemy
firing directly at them. I respect their courage for doing so.While
they are physically and mentally fitter than infantry, they are
just as vunerrable to bullets and grenades as any human soldiers.
The style of Cdo Atec is flawed. Special ops are very difficult to
assess.
I have nothing agst any formation, I respect each and every of them
for their tough training. But i feel the style of Atec for Cdo
still have room for improvement. Maybe shld be like the Artillery
assessment.Its own separate type of assessment
