Singapore must help malaysia if indonesia attacks

last SG · 2007-06-15T00:19:57+00:00

aussie? with their 50,000 strong standing army... by the time the aussie can muster sufficient military manpower for war against indonesia... i think the wa...

Arapahoe SG

who ever fight MY will involved SG. U can't expect the round does not fall onto SG.

Oh sorry....it won't happen again!! Mr. Green

crusader91 SG

Dun be dumb.Indonesians are our enemy.Lee kwan yew's memoir states that some stupid indonesians want to invade singapore more than the malaysains who had the chance to do so when we dun even have an army at hat time and what's the point of allying with a country that is the most corrupted in the world?

We drop from first world to third world. Evil or Very Mad

LazerLordz SG

The TNI is our friend, not the politicians. Cool

Hellraiza SG

I thought its supposed to be "by the time they recover from their hangovers"

aljudvin SG

let them fight. when the war is over. singapore attack both countries. Mr. Green

<Precious> SG

No lah. S'pore cannot help one against another since we are all members of ASEAN.
But shud Indo attack Malaysia, Sg will help itself to Malaysia lor........ after the fight is over of course....... Mr. Green

aljudvin SG

let them fight. when the war is over. singapore attack both countries. Mr. Green

tankfanatic SG

i think indo cant rant all it can about attacking M. They will only end up 17thousand new indonesia.

Full fledge war with a commonwealth country which is still closely friend of the united kindom..who is active members of the UN ..... which its army were better equip and wel fed... which still have defensive agreement to deter the very thing that the indo want to do...is very unlikely.

4 million willing to die? i dont think so........ Laughing

M will definately get help from the FDPA (u can say what ever u want about FPDA... but i actually read the actual defence agreement) Aussies will definately come. M diplomatic front will definately wage diplomatic war in the UN... Indonesia will cried foul play....but who attack first? Indo will get the sanction..big time.

Singapore probably wont take side (a good desision) But will condemned Indo action in breaching the spirit of asean.

Short Ninja SG

A malay taxi driver who probably didnt even serve his National Service showing some patriotism wherereas we always hear the bitching and moaning coming from SAF soldiers and Reservists.Is this irony or do you think the driver was just jerking you off? Just wanted to know your opinion

Short Ninja SG

Forgive me if I may sound a bit like rookie or stookie but Singapore going to war with Malaysia is like me winning the Bigsweep and for Indonesia to go to war with Malaysia will be like me winning the Singapore Bigsweep twice in a year. Mr. Green

CM06 SG

...

If Indo prep for arms, Our north neighbour prep for arms, All of you, your HP will ring for mob also.

Dont be stupid, if they are going to war we will be mobilised into defence positions right away.

Why?

Who say it aint a bluff? I wayang you wayang, we fight then together eat the brainless bird by the side. So we must MOB.
Dont forget the National Day(or some other holiday) Incident when Indo Para into Southern Malaysia for an "exercise" that their generals "forget" to mention to us. We push button immediately leh.

Failure to follow the FPDA, will 100% must us unreliable(economic&political&military fallout with others) and what chance we have to use that when it's our turn instead?

So if there's an Indon Invasion on our Northern neighbour we will defend them. Else the first bombs on butterworth hit our men and crafts, the same thing will happen.

tripwire SG

you remind me of someone who said they will never see a second world war in their live time after having gone through the first... Wink

tripwire SG

FPDA dont include east malaysia... why? because the brits, Aussies, kiwis and singapore are alot smarter then you think... Twisted Evil

and dont think that indonesia is so incompetent that it cannot take out east malaysia given its resources, manpower and geographical proximity...

i would be truely be surprised if malaysia could even reinforce its forces in east malaysia given its present military strength and troop lift capability across indonesian waters. Wink

while the indonesians could muster up to ten times the number of troops on kalimantan then malaysia have currently defending east malaysia covering a common land border stretching for nearly 1000 km long.... Wink indonesia clearly have the upper hand...

oh... i read the actual FPDA agreedment too... trust me... east malaysia aint in it... i dont have the document with me yet...

the best i could find on the net is this for the moment...

the FPDA only provides for the defence of Singapore and peninsular Malaysia (it
doesn't include east Malaysia).

http://www.unitedcommonwealth.org/AUKMIN.pdf

tripwire SG

so wat if indonesia is corrupted? isit our place to judge them? the govt of singapore only concern is the welfare and benefits of singapore...

and no one are forever enemy nor forever friends...

tripwire SG

here u have to differentiate between east and west malaysia... bombs in east malaysia wont hit us... its too far...

singapore do not have any obligation to defend east malaysia... in fact... we cant help even if we want to... anyone here in SAF wanna go fight the indonesians in east malaysia? Twisted Evil

tripwire SG

that is if singapore joins the looser lah... that would be malaysia... but if join indonesia.. and maybe even persuade thailand to join in the gang slam on malaysia... dont win also difficult... Mr. Green

tripwire SG

there is really no need to threaten singapore... a simple message from indonesia president to join them to wack malaysia is all that is needed to convince the ever so calculative, self serving singapore govt to realise where the gold is.
Twisted Evil

Short Ninja SG

I say this because of the Singapore overblown defense budget and looking at the SAF today.Also believing that Malaysia is more afraid of war and not the other way around.

tripwire SG

sideing with indonesia is probably like stalin signing peace treaty with germany prior to WW2...

but helping malaysia against indonesia is way too unrealistic for any pragmatic singapore govt....

as LKY also said... most singaporeans didnt even realise that indonesia territory stretch as long east to west as american east coast to west coast. Wink

tripwire SG

i am sure that malaysia are not afraid of war... because they never been in one eversince they gained independence. Wink same for us... Mr. Green

« Previous Page Next Page »